Welcome to the Judaism community on Codidact!
Will you help us build our community of learners? Drop into our study hall, ask questions, help others with answers to their questions, share a d'var torah if you're so inclined, invite your friends, and join us in building this community together. Not an ask-the-rabbi service, just people at all levels learning together.
Comments on Why are Matzah and Sukkah different in terms of intent?
Post
Why are Matzah and Sukkah different in terms of intent?
Bottom line question is why is a Sukkah different from a Matzah in terms of (not) requiring (expressed) kavannah in its creation?
A Sukkah (according to the ruling of Beit Hillel on Mas Sukkah 9a) need not be made specifically to be a sukkah. Even the schach, strictly speaking, does not need to be put on l'shem Sukkah. Theoretically, if I walked through a war zone on Sukkot and saw a shell of a house on which branches happen to have fallen, and it conforms to the rules of a kosher Sukkah, I can use it as such. Similarly, if a non-Jew builds my Sukkah, I can use it and make the bracha of "leisheiv." [according to Artscroll, the Yerushalmi instructs a Jew to make a minor adjustment but that doesn't seem to be a sine qua non of kashrut]
But Matzah requires an expressed Kavannah -- that the matzah being made is being made specifically for the sake of the mitzvah of eating matzah http://rabbi.bendory.com/cgi-bin/album/matzo/67 So if a non-Jew were to make it, it still needs the supervision of a Jew to ensure that someone has the right intent during the creation https://www.yeshiva.co/midrash/7405
BTW, the knotting of tzitzit also requires expressing an intent when making it but I don't know if the tying of the knot in tefillin shel rosh does also.
Why would matzah require a particular and expressed intent but a Sukkah would not?
1 comment thread