This is a research-methods question with a concrete example. I'm interested in the answer to the concrete example, but what I really want to know is: how could I look this up myself?

There are sometimes widespread patterns in torah. For example, I know about the reversing vav, which flips a verb from perfect to imperfect or vice versa. I know this happens all over torah, and I know the torah uses the "regular" perfect and imperfect verb forms in many places. When the torah uses one of these approaches consistently in a section, that doesn't seem particularly remarkable. But I came across a case where both forms are used in the same passage: in Bereishit 22:20-24 the torah uses both יָלְדָה and וַתֵּלֶד. The commentaries I found there don't talk about this, but if this is the Nth occurrence of that sort of thing, why would they? All I can tell from the absence of commentary is that there's apparently nothing special specifically about contrasting Milkah and R'umah. But that doesn't get me any closer to my answer.

If I had a question about specific words, I could use a concordance to find the first occurrence and look there. If the words were uncommon enough, I could even look up all the occurrences. But, short of reading from the beginning, I don't know how to find the first occurrence of both of these verb forms in close proximity. And maybe I'm thinking about it all wrong; maybe I shouldn't be looking for commentary anchored to a specific passage when it's something widespread, but should instead be checking somewhere else. But where?

How do I learn how to learn -- how to find commentaries about "meta" issues when I come across an instance?

posted about 2 years ago

CC BY-SA 4.0

Monica Cellio‭ staff

2631 reputation 102 53 377 98