Welcome to the Judaism community on Codidact!
Will you help us build our community of learners? Drop into our study hall, ask questions, help others with answers to their questions, share a d'var torah if you're so inclined, invite your friends, and join us in building this community together. Not an ask-the-rabbi service, just people at all levels learning together.
Post History
I was taught that we shouldn't make an interruption between saying a mitzvah b'racha and taking the action. I don't have a source for this other than that it makes sense; you don't want to risk ma...
#2: Post edited
by
Monica Cellio
·
2021-09-02T01:12:38Z (over 2 years ago)
motivation
- I was taught that we shouldn't make an interruption between saying a *mitzvah* *b'racha* and taking the action. I don't have a source for this other than that it makes sense; you don't want to risk making a blessing in vain if you interrupt with something else and never get back to it, and you should be maintaining the intention throughout, without distractions. I have two related questions: delays and interruptions.
- First, is *any* interruption a problem or is there some minimum in terms of either time or what it is? If the person called to the torah makes the blessing and the reader announces a verse number before reading, is that a problematic interruption? If a person makes the opening *haftarah* blessing and then says a couple sentences about the reading to provide context before starting, is that a problem? How much interruption is too much?
- Second, if there is no actual intervening activity (like introducing the portion), is there a length of delay that causes a problem? The reader can take a breath, the person making *motzi* can cut or tear the bread after finishing the blessing (on the way to eating), and in a group *havdalah* you might have to wait for the spice box to be passed to you. So the answer isn't "zero delay", but (if I learned correctly), an excessive delay is not ok. Is this a matter of judgement ("excessive" is based on the current context), or -- like the *matzah* at the Pesach *seder* that we have to eat within a specified number of minutes -- is there a *halachic* time limit?
For either, does it matter if the interruption was not reasonably foreseeable or something you could have planned for?
- I was taught that we shouldn't make an interruption between saying a *mitzvah* *b'racha* and taking the action. I don't have a source for this other than that it makes sense; you don't want to risk making a blessing in vain if you interrupt with something else and never get back to it, and you should be maintaining the intention throughout, without distractions. I have two related questions: delays and interruptions.
- First, is *any* interruption a problem or is there some minimum in terms of either time or what it is? If the person called to the torah makes the blessing and the reader announces a verse number before reading, is that a problematic interruption? If a person makes the opening *haftarah* blessing and then says a couple sentences about the reading to provide context before starting, is that a problem? How much interruption is too much?
- Second, if there is no actual intervening activity (like introducing the portion), is there a length of delay that causes a problem? The reader can take a breath, the person making *motzi* can cut or tear the bread after finishing the blessing (on the way to eating), and in a group *havdalah* you might have to wait for the spice box to be passed to you. So the answer isn't "zero delay", but (if I learned correctly), an excessive delay is not ok. Is this a matter of judgement ("excessive" is based on the current context), or -- like the *matzah* at the Pesach *seder* that we have to eat within a specified number of minutes -- is there a *halachic* time limit?
- For either, does it matter if the interruption was not reasonably foreseeable or something you could have planned for?
- (I'm asking this question as a teacher, to help me judge when I need to be urging more of a sense of urgency, not as someone looking for excuses to delay.)
#1: Initial revision
by
Monica Cellio
·
2021-09-02T00:52:48Z (over 2 years ago)
How much of an interruption is permitted between a mitzvah blessing and the mitzvah?
I was taught that we shouldn't make an interruption between saying a *mitzvah* *b'racha* and taking the action. I don't have a source for this other than that it makes sense; you don't want to risk making a blessing in vain if you interrupt with something else and never get back to it, and you should be maintaining the intention throughout, without distractions. I have two related questions: delays and interruptions.
First, is *any* interruption a problem or is there some minimum in terms of either time or what it is? If the person called to the torah makes the blessing and the reader announces a verse number before reading, is that a problematic interruption? If a person makes the opening *haftarah* blessing and then says a couple sentences about the reading to provide context before starting, is that a problem? How much interruption is too much?
Second, if there is no actual intervening activity (like introducing the portion), is there a length of delay that causes a problem? The reader can take a breath, the person making *motzi* can cut or tear the bread after finishing the blessing (on the way to eating), and in a group *havdalah* you might have to wait for the spice box to be passed to you. So the answer isn't "zero delay", but (if I learned correctly), an excessive delay is not ok. Is this a matter of judgement ("excessive" is based on the current context), or -- like the *matzah* at the Pesach *seder* that we have to eat within a specified number of minutes -- is there a *halachic* time limit?
For either, does it matter if the interruption was not reasonably foreseeable or something you could have planned for?