Welcome to the Judaism community on Codidact!
Will you help us build our community of learners? Drop into our study hall, ask questions, help others with answers to their questions, share a d'var torah if you're so inclined, invite your friends, and join us in building this community together. Not an ask-the-rabbi service, just people at all levels learning together.
Post History
The Rama (to OC 425:1) cites both customs: the usual rosh chodesh reading, and the usual weekly ("punishment") reading. He says "in a place with no established practice" read the rosh chodesh read...
Answer
#4: Post edited
by
msh210
·
2021-07-07T05:59:59Z (almost 3 years ago)
oops
The _Rama_ (to _OC_ 425:1) cites both customs: the usual _rosh chodesh_ reading, and the usual weekly ("punishment") reading. He says "in a place with no established practice" read the _rosh chodesh_ reading. _G'ra_ there proves that the usual weekly reading is sounder, and _Mishna B'rura_ seems to follow him. [It seems](//chabad.org/2278243) the penultimate Lubavitcher rebbe read the usual weekly reading, after some confusion. _Aruch Hashulchan_ (:5) writes much like the _Rama_, noting also that his own local custom is to read the _rosh chodesh_ reading. I don't know communities' current customs.- This is specifically about _rosh chodesh Av_. Other special weeks have other rules.
- The _Rama_ (to _OC_ 425:1) cites both customs: the usual _rosh chodesh_ reading, and the usual weekly ("punishment") reading. He says "in a place with no established practice" read the _rosh chodesh_ reading. _G'ra_ there proves that the usual weekly reading is sounder, and _Mishna B'rura_ seems to follow him. [It seems](//chabad.org/2278243) the fifth Lubavitcher rebbe read the usual weekly reading, after some confusion. _Aruch Hashulchan_ (:5) writes much like the _Rama_, noting also that his own local custom is to read the _rosh chodesh_ reading. I don't know communities' current customs.
- This is specifically about _rosh chodesh Av_. Other special weeks have other rules.
#3: Post edited
by
msh210
·
2021-07-07T05:58:47Z (almost 3 years ago)
clarify
The _Rama_ (to _OC_ 425:1) cites both customs: the usual _rosh chodesh_ reading, and the usual weekly ("punishment") reading. He says "in a place with no established practice" read the _rosh chodesh_ reading. _G'ra_ there proves that the usual weekly reading is sounder, and _Mishna B'rura_ seems to follow him. [It seems](//chabad.org/2278243) the Lubavitcher rebbe read the usual weekly reading, after some confusion. _Aruch Hashulchan_ (:5) writes much like the _Rama_, noting also that his own local custom is to read the _rosh chodesh_ reading. I don't know communities' current customs.- This is specifically about _rosh chodesh Av_. Other special weeks have other rules.
- The _Rama_ (to _OC_ 425:1) cites both customs: the usual _rosh chodesh_ reading, and the usual weekly ("punishment") reading. He says "in a place with no established practice" read the _rosh chodesh_ reading. _G'ra_ there proves that the usual weekly reading is sounder, and _Mishna B'rura_ seems to follow him. [It seems](//chabad.org/2278243) the penultimate Lubavitcher rebbe read the usual weekly reading, after some confusion. _Aruch Hashulchan_ (:5) writes much like the _Rama_, noting also that his own local custom is to read the _rosh chodesh_ reading. I don't know communities' current customs.
- This is specifically about _rosh chodesh Av_. Other special weeks have other rules.
#2: Post edited
by
msh210
·
2021-07-07T03:52:01Z (almost 3 years ago)
The _Rama_ (to _OC_ 425:1) cites both customs: the usual _rosh chodesh_ reading, and the usual weekly ("punishment") reading. He says "in a place with no established practice" read the _rosh chodesh_ reading. _G'ra_ there proves that the usual weekly reading is sounder, and _Mishna B'rura_ seems to follow him. [It seems](//chabad.org/2278243) the Lubavitcher rebbe read the usual weekly reading, after some confusion. _Aruch Hashulchan_ (:5) writes much like the _Rama_, noting also that his own local custom is to read the _rosh chodesh_ reading. I don't know communities' current customs.
- The _Rama_ (to _OC_ 425:1) cites both customs: the usual _rosh chodesh_ reading, and the usual weekly ("punishment") reading. He says "in a place with no established practice" read the _rosh chodesh_ reading. _G'ra_ there proves that the usual weekly reading is sounder, and _Mishna B'rura_ seems to follow him. [It seems](//chabad.org/2278243) the Lubavitcher rebbe read the usual weekly reading, after some confusion. _Aruch Hashulchan_ (:5) writes much like the _Rama_, noting also that his own local custom is to read the _rosh chodesh_ reading. I don't know communities' current customs.
- This is specifically about _rosh chodesh Av_. Other special weeks have other rules.
#1: Initial revision
by
msh210
·
2021-07-07T03:50:27Z (almost 3 years ago)
The _Rama_ (to _OC_ 425:1) cites both customs: the usual _rosh chodesh_ reading, and the usual weekly ("punishment") reading. He says "in a place with no established practice" read the _rosh chodesh_ reading. _G'ra_ there proves that the usual weekly reading is sounder, and _Mishna B'rura_ seems to follow him. [It seems](//chabad.org/2278243) the Lubavitcher rebbe read the usual weekly reading, after some confusion. _Aruch Hashulchan_ (:5) writes much like the _Rama_, noting also that his own local custom is to read the _rosh chodesh_ reading. I don't know communities' current customs.