Welcome to the Judaism community on Codidact!
Will you help us build our community of learners? Drop into our study hall, ask questions, help others with answers to their questions, share a d'var torah if you're so inclined, invite your friends, and join us in building this community together. Not an ask-the-rabbi service, just people at all levels learning together.
Post History
I know that t'fillin are placed on the weaker arm, which for most people is the left, so that the stronger hand is the one doing the binding. I have heard, but don't remember where, that someone w...
Question
tefillin
#2: Post edited
by
Monica Cellio
·
2021-04-29T03:46:47Z (over 3 years ago)
clarification
- I know that *t'fillin* are placed on the weaker arm, which for most people is the left, so that the stronger hand is the one doing the binding. I have heard, but don't remember where, that someone who is ambidextrous uses the left as well, since the right isn't *weaker* and the left is more common.
- What about someone who was born left-handed but then was "trained" to be right-handed? While *t'fillin* doesn't apply to me (and so I ask this just out of curiosity), I'm one of those people -- by nature I am left-handed, but due to some superstitious adults in my early life, I was taught everything right-handed instead. My left arm is *stronger*, but my right hand is more *dextrous*. I know several other people like this. (None of them are Jewish men, though, so I can't ask what they do.)
Would someone like this proceed as a right-hander, because that's how that person functions now? Or would that person instead proceed as a left-hander, because that is the way God made that person? (We apply the same principle in modern gender matters, as I understand it.)
- I know that *t'fillin* are placed on the weaker arm, which for most people is the left, so that the stronger hand is the one doing the binding. I have heard, but don't remember where, that someone who is ambidextrous uses the left as well, since the right isn't *weaker* and the left is more common.
- What about someone who was born left-handed but then was "trained" to be right-handed? While *t'fillin* doesn't apply to me (and so I ask this just out of curiosity), I'm one of those people -- by nature I am left-handed, but due to some superstitious adults in my early life, I was taught everything right-handed instead. My left arm is *stronger*, but my right hand is more *dextrous*. I know several other people like this. (None of them are Jewish men, though, so I can't ask what they do.)
- Would someone like this proceed as a right-hander, because that's how that person functions now? Or would that person instead proceed as a left-hander, because that is the way God made that person? (We apply the latter principle in modern gender matters, as I understand it.)
#1: Initial revision
by
Monica Cellio
·
2021-04-29T00:04:16Z (over 3 years ago)
Handedness for t'fillin: nature or nurture?
I know that *t'fillin* are placed on the weaker arm, which for most people is the left, so that the stronger hand is the one doing the binding. I have heard, but don't remember where, that someone who is ambidextrous uses the left as well, since the right isn't *weaker* and the left is more common. What about someone who was born left-handed but then was "trained" to be right-handed? While *t'fillin* doesn't apply to me (and so I ask this just out of curiosity), I'm one of those people -- by nature I am left-handed, but due to some superstitious adults in my early life, I was taught everything right-handed instead. My left arm is *stronger*, but my right hand is more *dextrous*. I know several other people like this. (None of them are Jewish men, though, so I can't ask what they do.) Would someone like this proceed as a right-hander, because that's how that person functions now? Or would that person instead proceed as a left-hander, because that is the way God made that person? (We apply the same principle in modern gender matters, as I understand it.)