Welcome to the Judaism community on Codidact!
Will you help us build our community of learners? Drop into our study hall, ask questions, help others with answers to their questions, share a d'var torah if you're so inclined, invite your friends, and join us in building this community together. Not an ask-the-rabbi service, just people at all levels learning together.
Post History
Asking this question reminded me of another. As part of my (past) musical studies, I've studied historical compositions that set the "ordinary" of the Christian mass to music. The "ordinary" cons...
#2: Post edited
by
Monica Cellio
·
2020-11-17T00:57:05Z (about 4 years ago)
- Asking [this question](https://judaism.codidact.com/questions/279263) reminded me of another.
- As part of my (past) musical studies, I've studied historical compositions that set the "ordinary" of the Christian mass to music. The "ordinary" consists of five key prayer texts that are frequently (always?) part of the mass. Four of them are blatantly problematic for Jews in terms of content. The fifth, [Sanctus (Wikipedia)](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sanctus#Sanctus_as_section_of_the_Mass_ordinary), focuses on God's glory and doesn't talk about other parts of the Christian trinity. (It's clearly related to our Kedusha.) As a student studying this music for its musical, not textual, properties, I once composed a setting of the Sanctus text. (Sure wasn't going to choose one of the others! That was a visceral reaction; I was not observant then.)
- Looking back on that time now, I wonder whether setting a *text* that contains no objectionable religious references, but comes from a religious context, is permitted. Does context matter -- university assignment versus personal project, where (or if) it will be performed, perhaps other factors?
- Asking [this question](https://judaism.codidact.com/questions/279263) reminded me of another.
- As part of my (past) musical studies, I've studied historical compositions that set the "ordinary" of the Christian mass to music. The "ordinary" consists of five key prayer texts that are frequently (always?) part of the mass. Four of them are blatantly problematic for Jews in terms of content. The fifth, [Sanctus (Wikipedia)](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sanctus#Sanctus_as_section_of_the_Mass_ordinary), focuses on God's glory and doesn't talk about other parts of the Christian trinity. (It's clearly related to our Kedusha.) As a student studying this music for its musical, not textual, properties, I once composed a setting of the Sanctus text. (Sure wasn't going to choose one of the others! That was a visceral reaction; I was not observant then.)
- Looking back on that time now, I wonder whether setting a *text* that contains no objectionable religious references, but comes from a religious context, is permitted. Does context matter -- university assignment versus personal project, where (or if) it will be performed, perhaps other factors?
- (Just in case anybody is concerned, this is not a practical matter for me. I am no longer a university student and when I want to do choral composition I use more suitable texts. I'm just curious.)
#1: Initial revision
by
Monica Cellio
·
2020-11-17T00:53:08Z (about 4 years ago)
If the words come from Christian worship but aren't otherwise objectionable, can you use them for secular music?
Asking [this question](https://judaism.codidact.com/questions/279263) reminded me of another. As part of my (past) musical studies, I've studied historical compositions that set the "ordinary" of the Christian mass to music. The "ordinary" consists of five key prayer texts that are frequently (always?) part of the mass. Four of them are blatantly problematic for Jews in terms of content. The fifth, [Sanctus (Wikipedia)](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sanctus#Sanctus_as_section_of_the_Mass_ordinary), focuses on God's glory and doesn't talk about other parts of the Christian trinity. (It's clearly related to our Kedusha.) As a student studying this music for its musical, not textual, properties, I once composed a setting of the Sanctus text. (Sure wasn't going to choose one of the others! That was a visceral reaction; I was not observant then.) Looking back on that time now, I wonder whether setting a *text* that contains no objectionable religious references, but comes from a religious context, is permitted. Does context matter -- university assignment versus personal project, where (or if) it will be performed, perhaps other factors?