Welcome to the Judaism community on Codidact!
Will you help us build our community of learners? Drop into our study hall, ask questions, help others with answers to their questions, share a d'var torah if you're so inclined, invite your friends, and join us in building this community together. Not an ask-the-rabbi service, just people at all levels learning together.
Post History
In the original printing of Sdei Chemed (about 18 volumes, some posthumous) there was a kuntrus adjoined at the end of the fifth volume (I saw this on the oztar hachochma). This kuntrus entitled ב...
#2: Post edited
by
Dr. Shmuel
·
2020-10-09T19:30:26Z (about 4 years ago)
In the original printing of Sdei Chemed (about 18 volumes, some posthumous) there was a kuntrus adjoined at the end of the fifth volume (I saw this on the oztar hachochma; link forthcoming). This kuntrus entitled באר בשדי (also available as a stand-alone volume on Hebrewbooks.org) is a 32 page rebuttal to the sanctity of the title the author chose for his encyclopedic work.- Recently I saw a reprinting from the last century, split into a total of 9 volumes. However, after doing a little skimming through them, I still couldn’t find this kuntrus. Did this kuntrus make it into said reprint, if so, where?
- In the original printing of Sdei Chemed (about 18 volumes, some posthumous) there was a kuntrus adjoined at the end of the fifth volume (I saw this on the [oztar hachochma](https://tablet.otzar.org/en/pages/?&pagenum=173&book=617425)). This kuntrus entitled באר בשדי (also available as a stand-alone volume on[ Hebrewbooks.org](https://hebrewbooks.org/41977)) is a 32 page rebuttal to the sanctity of the title the author chose for his encyclopedic work.
- Recently I saw a reprinting from the last century, split into a total of 9 volumes. However, after doing a little skimming through them, I still couldn’t find this kuntrus. Did this kuntrus make it into said reprint, if so, where?
#1: Initial revision
by
Dr. Shmuel
·
2020-10-09T15:30:17Z (about 4 years ago)
In which volume is the Sdei Chemed’s rebuttal kuntrus printed?
In the original printing of Sdei Chemed (about 18 volumes, some posthumous) there was a kuntrus adjoined at the end of the fifth volume (I saw this on the oztar hachochma; link forthcoming). This kuntrus entitled באר בשדי (also available as a stand-alone volume on Hebrewbooks.org) is a 32 page rebuttal to the sanctity of the title the author chose for his encyclopedic work. Recently I saw a reprinting from the last century, split into a total of 9 volumes. However, after doing a little skimming through them, I still couldn’t find this kuntrus. Did this kuntrus make it into said reprint, if so, where?